Loading...

Lesson: Challenging Critical/Logical Reasoning - 15t01

Reasoning Classics: The Scope Shift Argument, continued

[Page 15 of 24]

The extent to which a society is really free can be gauged by its attitude toward artistic expression. Freedom of expression can easily be violated in even the most outwardly democratic of societies. When a government arts council withholds funding from a dance performance that its members deem "obscene," the voices of a few bureaucrats have in fact censored the work of the choreographer, thereby committing the real obscenity of repression.

Which of the following, if true, would most seriously weaken the argument above?

Members of government arts councils are screened to ensure that their beliefs reflect those of the majority.
The term obscenity has several definitions that should not be used interchangeably for rhetorical effect.
Failing to provide financial support for a performance is not the same as actively preventing or inhibiting it.
The council's decision could be reversed if the performances were altered to conform to public standards of appropriateness.
The definition of obscenity is something on which most members of a society can agree.

The author is making a conclusion about censoring the work of the choreographer, but is using evidence about the funding of the choreographer's work. Refusing to fund a work of art is different from actively censoring the work. Choice (C) calls attention to the scope shift, and thus weakens the argument.

Scope shifts are one of the most common logical flaws in Reasoning arguments. If a question asks you to identify an error in the author's reasoning, or to weaken the argument, be on the lookout for scope shifts.

Back Next div>

Next to display next topic in the chapter.

Video Lessons and 10 Fully Explained Grand Tests

Large number of solved practice MCQ with explanations. Video Lessons and 10 Fully explained Grand/Full Tests.

Current Menu
More for You
All in this Category

You may be interested in

PAF College Sargodha

Admission detail for admission in P ...

Colleges in cities of Punjab

Comprehensive lists of colleges in ...

Admissions News and Info

Have current admission news and inf ...

World Organizations and General Issues

A list of Essays on World Organizat ...

ISSB Tests

Learn about ISSB - Armed forces rec ...

ISSB Tests

How to deal with ISSB Recruitment t ...

Aga Khan Medical University

AKU is the top ranked maedical univ ...

SZABIST - Engineering

SZABIST - Mechatronics Engineering ...